Kadyrov Says ‘Putin Will Determine My Future’ and ‘Government Didn’t Need Nemtsov’s Death’

March 2, 2016
Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov. Photo by abacapress/vostok

LIVE UPDATES: Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov denied he had any hostility toward slain opposition leader Boris Nemtsov and said the suspects had no motivation or organization to kill him. He also said President Vladimir Putin will determine his future after his term ends this month.

Welcome to our column, Russia Update, where we will be closely following day-to-day developments in Russia, including the Russian government’s foreign and domestic policies.

The previous issue is here.

Recent Translations:
How Boris Nemtsov Was Murdered: Investigation by Novaya Gazeta
The Non-Hybrid War
Kashin Explains His ‘Letter to Leaders’ on ‘Fontanka Office’
TV Rain Interviews Volunteer Fighter Back from Donbass


Uzbek Nanny With History of Schizophrenia Confesses to Murder of Russian Child; Says ‘Allah Ordered’ Her

Gyulchekhra Bobokulova, the Uzbek nanny accused of murdering a Russian child in Moscow, was brought before a Moscow court today and her detention until April 29 was approved by a judge, Novaya Gazeta reported.
Before the hearing, she told reporters that she had confessed to the murder and that “Allah had ordered” her to kill the child. She is expected to be arraigned March 4.
Early news reports indicated she was possibly under the influence of a drug and also had a history of involuntary hospitalization for schizophrenia.
On February 29, Bobokulova, who has been mentally disabled since birth, was reported to have murdered the 4-year-old girl in her care after her parents and older brother left the house. She then went to the Oktyabrskoye Pole metro stop where she paraded for half an hour while waving the child’s severed head and crying “Allahu Akhbar!” and then threatening to blow herself up.
Public complaints that the police had taken a long time to arrest Bobokulova led to explanations that law-enforcers had blocked metro entrances near the area and eventually detained her after half an hour. Under Russian law, police are not allowed to shoot women even in extreme circumstances but a law already before the parliament would increase police powers to do just that.
Russian state media did not report the story, which led to protests of censorship from opposition leader Alexey Navalny, who filed a complaint under Russian law guaranteeing freedom of expression.
While the Kremlin claimed it had not mandated the news blackout, RBC reported that officials were concerned about inciting ethnic hatred in a climate in which many Russians, notably Navalny himself, have objected to Central Asian and other non-Russian migrant laborers in Russia.

— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick

Russian Institute for Human Rights Wins Court Appeal of Fine for ‘Foreign Agent’ Status

Novaya Gazeta reports that the Ostankino District Court in Moscow has vacated the judgement of a justice of the peace who  had declared the Institute for Human Rights guilty of violating the procedure for NGOs requiring registration as a “foreign agent” if an organization engages in unspecified “political activity” and receives funds from abroad.

The Institute’s lawyer Damir Gaynutdinov said their case had been sent for new review but the statute of limitations has expired and the court is obliged to close the case.

The Institute for Human Rights is a long-standing non-profit organization devoted to research and policy proposals on human rights issues. Its president is Sergei Kovalev, a biologist and close friend of Dr. Andrei Sakharov, the Nobel Peace Prize laureate. Kovalev, a former political prisoner, chairman of Memorial Society and former member of parliament frequently writes essays critical of the Kremlin, notably about Russian aggression in Chechnya, Ukraine and Syria but has not joined in organized opposition activity.

With this decision, Russian authorities may have drawn the line where they will prosecute “foreign agents,” but it will remain puzzling to many as numerous other groups — including the Sakharov Center, where Kovalev has also been active — have hewed to human rights rather than “political” agendas, even if they are critical of current policy, and yet have had to pay the 300,000 ruble fine.

— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick 

Interfax Interview with Kadyrov: ‘Putin Will Determine My Future’; ‘Government Did Not Need Nemtsov’s Death’
Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov put himself at the top of the headlines again today by saying “Putin will determine my future” and denying that he or his father Akhmat had any hostility to slain opposition leader Boris Nemtsov, saying Akhmat had even shook Nemtsov’s hand when Nemtsov came to Grozny in the 2000s in an effort to stop the war.
In a lengthy interview with Interfax, Kadyrov spoke about his future plans, as less than a month remains of his term in office. He discarded any notion of democratic elections by the people of Chechnya and said the prerogative to chose the candidates belonged to the Kremlin. 
“Any decision on this question is made by Vladimir Putin, President of Russia. And I am a foot soldier who will say ‘Yes, sir!'”
Kadyrov said that due to Chechens now serving in the federal Russian army, and young people coming to vacation spots in Chechnya from other republics, “the full integration of Chechen society in the family of nations of Russia” had taken place. But “not everyone likes this” and he had enemies.
Asked under what conditions he would remain, he said that if Putin ordered him to stay, he would. If he didn’t, Kadyrov said he would become more involved in his family and raising and educating his 9 children; a father should spend at least an hour a day with each son, he said.
As for the five Chechen men held as suspects in the murder, two of whom were officers in the Chechen Interior Ministry’s Internal Troops sometimes described as Kadyrov’s “personal army,” Kadyrov said “how could such a group commit the murder of Nemtsov”?  He said they “didn’t represent anything” and “couldn’t have “united to organize the conspiracy and murder.” He denied that Nemtsov’s death “was needed by the government at any level.”
Kadyrov also claimed that he had not defended the accused as such but only “expressed his own opinion” when he called Zaur Dadayev, said to be the trigger man, “a true patriot.” He said when asked a direct question about Dadayev by a reporter he didn’t lie, but said Dadayev had “fearlessly fought terrorists.” A group  of terrorists who had killed people, bombed cars and destroyed homes were “neutralized” through Dadayev’s efforts, said Kadyrov.
Moscow City Court has extended the pre-trial arrest period of the five suspects until May 28. There are 66 volumes of case files which have been shown to Nemtsov’s family, and will now be given to the suspects to read. During a hearing March 1, the suspects again denied their guilt and said they gave confessions under torture. The judge reprimanded their lawyers; one for looking at a tablet and laughing during the session and another for calling the Russian justice system “an organized crime group.”

Interfax asked Kadyrov if he feared any criminal prosecution for his threats against the opposition, including posting a surveillance tape of Parnas opposition party chair Mikhail Kasyanov and journalist Vladimir Kara-Murza, Jr. shown through a sniper’s scope.

Kadyrov ducked the question and took the occasion to once again blame the opposition for not behaving as he believed an opposition should, and castigating them because while some of them were in power (Kasyanov was Putin’s prime minister), they ostensibly didn’t have complaints then. Kadyrov said (translation by The Interpreter):

“If we speak about Mikhail Kasyanov, then there has never been a more gray personality in politics. All of his work consists of systematic trips around the capitals of Western countries. What purposes do these people pursue? Very simple. I don’t doubt one bit that that they have absolutely no serious goals. The plans of actions are most likely written up at the US State Department, and the details are received from various types of specific ministries in the West, possibly even intelligence agencies. The task is set to them to destabilize the situation in the country from inside, to raise the population, to provoke street actions, try to force the use of force, and distract all the attention of the country’s leadership from foreign policy tasks, and force the Kremlin to refrain from taking part in solving world problems…

The danger is that to this day, no appropriate measures of counteraction have been taken. Kasyanov and others systematically meet with representatives of the West, obtain instructions from them, and possibly a solid financial support. They are not embarrassed by this. They openly advise our non-friends (read: enemies), where the strike should be made in order to disrupt the economy, to provoke political instability. If Kasyanov was a patriot, at this difficult time for Russia, he would tell the president and the prime minister that he would like to put his shoulder to the wheel, he is ready to be a consultant, a minister’s aide, an advisor, that he does not need positions and power.

Of course such people pose a threat for the economic, political and social security of Russia. I think even a military threat as well. Kasyanov and some other former officials most likely are the bearers of state secrets, and there is no certainty that they will not share them.

We need to call a spade a spade. War has virtually been declared against us. Economic, diplomatic, information and ideological. The advance guard, the paratroopers are already in Russia. These Kasyanovs and others. I did not mount a photo of Kasyanov with the scope, and did not place it in the Internet. The photo or video there, I don’t recall, was sent to me by someone who said it was from the Internet. I thought it was funny that a former prime minister and ‘leader of the opposition’ abroad was holding some secret meetings, hiding from Russian journalists. This is funny. And once again, ‘who doesn’t understand, will’ means, for those who still haven’t figured out what Kasyanov represents, they will see and understand when they learn that he went for his latest hand-out. Kasyanov was only waiting for this. ‘Oh, they’re threatening me,’ and so on…Who is threatening him, why, for what reason, whom does he personally bother? Nobody. A pathetic person, who has lost himself, running around the offices of petty Western bureaucrat. That is humiliating for the former prime minister of a great country.”

As for the cake attacks, Kadyrov urged Kasyanov to man up and take his licks, as politicians should expect such things.
Interfax then asked Kadyrov how many fighters from Chechnya were in the “ranks of the implacable opposition,” as the reporter put it. What was Chechnya doing to “neutralzie” these fighters? Was a fear that they would return home and destabilize the situation?

Kadyrov said 250-300 natives of Chechnya, including both Russian citizens and residents of Europe, were in Syria and Iraq. He said volunteers “who have no relationship to military service of the Interior Ministry” were tracking such fighters “at the risk of their own lives” and they “had personal scores to settle, and these were settled, even if the bandits tried to hide.” He said no fighter would be allowed to get back into Russia and said he doubted they would be able to.

“First, they don’t live long there, and second they understand perfectly well that penetrating Russia will be very difficult for them,” he explained.

On February 29, presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the Kremlin would not comment on Kadyrov until the end of his term.
— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick
AM Russian Headlines: Oil Companies Not to Increase Production; Kadyrov Says ‘Putin Will Determine My Future’

Ruble to dollar exchange 73.52; ruble to euro 79.81; Brent crude $36.89 per barrel.

The following headlines were drawn from Deutsche Welle, Interfax, RBC, Novaya Gazeta, Gazeta, Free Beacon, Vedomosti,  

— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick