LIVE UPDATES: Supporters of opposition leader Alexey Navalny have debated the Constitutional interpretation of Russian law that might allow him to run for president despite his recent criminal conviction. But federal law is not on his side.
The previous issue is here.
Recent Analysis and Translations:
‘Hybrid Cyberwars’: Are the Russian Hackers’ Arrests About American or Internal Russian issues?
Donât Forget About âSoft Powerâ Part of Russiaâs âHybrid Warâ in Ukraine: Russian Activist Yashinâs New Report
Russiaâs Propaganda War Against Ukraine: Interview with Russian Opposition Activist Ilya Yashin
How Many Russians Are Fighting for ISIS? A Brief History of The Kremlinâs Arbitrary Numbers
Aleksei Navalny, Viable Putin Rival, Is Barred From a Presidential Run
Since he first came to power in January 2000, Mr. Putin and his allies have gone to great lengths to silence or undermine all critical voices in Russia. It has been almost two years since the still-mysterious assassination of Boris Nemtsov, another charismatic opposition figure, on the doorstep of the Kremlin.
Constitutional Interpretation in Navalny’s Favor
But some commentators objected that under the Constitution, technically, Navalny could run.
Translation: Why will Navalny’s election campaign continue? The Constitution of the Russian Federation has the answer.
Navalny himself wrote that he would continue regardless:
Russian Constitution Routinely Violated
If only the Russian Constitution prevailed on so many things! Such as Art. 31, on the right to peaceful assembly, or the right to freedom of the media — there are lots of rights in the Constitution that are either undone by federal law or internal ministerial instructions or simply political will. Russia is a civil-law country with very weak precedent in constitutional rulings; it is not like the common-law countries such as the US where a Supreme Court ruling becomes the law of the land.
The problem with the hopeful legal analysis of Navalny supporters is that it overlooks the power of the political decision that didn’t stop with the overturning of Navalny’s Kirovles sentence by the Russian Supreme Court (separate from the Constitutional Court) — a startling development in itself, soon proven irrelevant as the case was re-opened at the local court — with obvious pressure from Moscow.
And in fact, the Kremlin does have law to cite to keep Navalny out of the race.
Federal Law Bars Navalny from Race
In an angry Facebook post, Vladimir Milov, an opposition member, former deputy energy minister and president of the Institute of Energy Policy explained his realization, after some research, as to why the authorities will have legal grounds to bar Navalny from the elections.
While the Russian Constitution does state that only a person “in a place of imprisonment under a court sentence” would be barred from taking part in a campaign, the Federal Law on the Basic Guarantees of Election Rights and Rights to Take Part in Referendum of Citizens of the Russian Federation (Art. 4, point 3.2) has a list of grounds for not enjoying the right to take part in elections, in addition to the two exceptions listed in the constitution.
The federal law says those who cannot be elected include persons “sentenced to imprisonment for the commission of serious crimes, who, on the day of election have a conviction that has not been overturned of served,” as well as persons with past convictions “for a period of 10 years” from the date the sentence was overturned or served.
Thus, persons with suspended sentences cannot run in elections, according to federal election law.
That applies to Navalny, with his new Kirovles sentence, which has not yet been overturned or served.
“Listen, but this has to be contested in Constitutional Court yesterday!!!”” cried Milov on Facebook, and the debate continued.
Further Arguments in Navalny’s Favor
Leonid Volkov, Navalny’s campaign manager, made much the same point in a blog post but then countered that other factors indicate Navalny could run even so.
So it might be, in a perfect world, either lawyers will successfully contest the unconstitutionality of the federal law, or contest Navalny’s specific sentence and get it overturned again, in time for the 2018 elections. This seems unlikely in Putin’s Russia.
How Do You Solve a Problem Like Navalny?
There’s some opinion that Putin “doesn’t know what to do” with Navalny which is why these contradictory developments have taken place — first a Supreme Court sentence seeming to abolish the Kirovles case, then a swift “re-investigation” and re-opening — in sessions where as we could see the obvious contrived nature of the proceedings from the live feed from the courtroom.
At one point, when the prosecutor didn’t seem to have any questions for him, Navalny, a lawyer, suggested questions he might ask. The judge and prosecutors present laughed out loud, as they did at other points suggesting “telephone law,” as it was known in the Soviet era, i.e. political direction, was at work. Navalny tweeted out pages of the sentence before it was even read by the judge.
But what’s more likely is that Putin — who is perfectly calculating and decisive on a whole range of issues from backing separatists shelling Avdeyevka after his phone call with President Donald Trump; to ordering the bombing of Syrian targets; to not apologizing, but merely expressing “condolences” when his planes kill 3 Turkish soldiers; to remaining silent as another one of his critics, Vladimir Kara-Murza, Jr. is poisoned; to signing into law removal of some domestic violence crimes and more — is simply testing to see if there is sufficient public opinion in support of Navalny to warrant appeasement and granting the semblance of democracy.
Since the elections are a year away, Putin can draw this out and either crush Navalny early in the race or let it drag on and find whatever legal interpretation is needed to suit his purpose. He can either discredit and demolish the opposition once again, or he can toy with them to gain the semblance of democratic legitimacy.
To see this process as “indecision” about Navalny or “conflict” among clans in the Kremlin is to ignore his treatment over the past years — frequent administrative and criminal charges to tie him up in courts and discredit him in the public eye; failure to register his party or allow him in any election so far; while allowing him just enough leeway to go on exposing various cronies of Putin’s such as Vladimir Yakovlev, the former CEO of Russian Railways, or Igor Shuvalov, vice premier — whom Putin himself needs to keep in line in his own highly selective battle against corruption.
Danger of Running a Campaign
Navalny himself vows to ignore these developments, which he has repeatedly characterized as unjust political persecution, and has launched his campaign in St. Petersburg.
Of course, judging from the fate of past independent candidates — smears on state TV, hecklers and even physical attacks at every meeting with voters, and provocations to force criminal charges — running a campaign is risky indeed.
In last year’s local elections in the summer and parliamentary elections in September, Volkov, for example was accused of “damaging a microphone” and “obstructing the media” (a criminal code article meant to protect journalists from the government) when a LifeNews reporter came to harass him at campaign headquarters.
At one point while traveling in support of independent candidates, Navalny was surrounded by Cossacks at an airport who started a brawl by slapping a ball out of the hands of a supporter who then slugged the provocateur. Another candidate who suspected provocateurs had larded his nomination signatures with deliberate fakes tried to check them with police and wounded up charged with improper access to personal data, as did the policeman.
The last opposition figure able to lead mass marches and get himself elected to local legislatures even as he sharply criticized Putin — Boris Nemtsov — was assassinated two years ago this month. A long line of such assassinations will give pause to any serious challenger to Putin’s re-election in 2018.
— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick