For links to individual updates click on the timestamps.
For the latest summary of evidence surrounding the shooting down of flight MH17 see our separate article: Evidence Review: Who Shot Down MH17?
The defense team for imprisoned pilot Nadiya (Nadezhda) Savchenko has released a video explaining how Russia’s claim that she was accomplice to the murder of Russian state journalists last year are not substantiated, Kiev Post reported.
Last year on June 17, 2014, Igor Kornylyuk and his sound man Anton Voloshyn from VGTRK (State TV and Radio Committee) were killed at a checkpoint in Lugansk region. Russian investigators claim Savchenko was a spotter for Ukrainian forces that supposedly deliberately targeted the camera crew.
But evidence gathered by Mark Feigin, a Moscow-based attorney and other lawyers defending Savchenko challenge the Kremlin’s claims.
Says the Kyiv Post:
The video gives a
reconstruction of a battle between Ukrainian troops and
Russian-separatist forces which began approximately at 6 a.m. on June
17, 2014. It uses Google Maps and detailed tracking of the mobile phones
of both Savchenko and the killed Russian journalists. The phone
tracking data was provided by the Security Service of Ukraine.
to the mobile tracking data, when Savchenko was taken captive near the
village of Stukalova Balka in Luhansk Oblast at 10 a.m., the journalists
were still in central Luhansk, some three kilometers from the place
where they were killed an hour later.
timing of Savchenko’s capturing was verified by Kyiv-based Research
Institute of Forensic Science that analyzed the position of the sun on
the video showing Savchenko captured. The video was shot and published
by the separatists.
was brought to Luhansk at 10:44 a.m., which is reflected in the video
of her interrogation, while Russian journalists left central Luhansk and
arrived into suburban Kombrod district in the northern part of the city
at 10:45 a.m., according to the eye-witness taxi driver.
Meanwhile after Savchenko was already captured, the team of Russian journalists was on its way to the checkpoint at Metalist at 11:00.
A video of the capture made by a separatist fighters also enables an analysis of the sun’s position by the Kiev Research Institute of Forensic Science.
A taxi driver who took the Russian journalists to the checkpoint said they were at the center of Lugansk at 10:26, at 10:45 in Kombrod by the outskirts of the city and they started toward the checkpoint around 11:00 — when Savchenko was already captured. The journalists were then killed at 11:40 am Kiev time.
They had already been filming in this area, embedded with
Russian-backed fighters the previous day and planned to return home on
June 17. But they went back to the checkpoint to follow up a claim —
never substantiated — made by an interview subject the day before that
Ukrainian forces supposedly stabbed everyone in a village. As we wrote:
Sound engineer Anton Voloshin was killed at the scene – the
village of Metalist [Metallist] village outside the city of Luhansk –
while a reporter, Igor Kornelyuk, died in hospital during surgery. A
third member of the crew survived.
This video provides some insight into what may have happened. It
starts off with the cameraman filming something smoking. The smoke gets
worse right before the explosion. Our best guess is that a mortar shell
had already landed there but did not detonate right away. After the
first explosion, several incoming shells can be heard, and there are
A possible alternative explanation is that the first explosion,
likely of whatever we see smoking at the start of the video, triggered
incoming fire. As the video starts after the incident has started, it’s
not entirely clear.
The film shows clearly that the journalists were at the checkpoint,
unprotected, and even dove for cover under APCs, all of which were
legitimate targets of war.
BBC correspondent Daniel Sandford was covering the war in Lugansk Region at the time and found a longer version of the video posted by RT.com.
In this video, several shells are heard to fall from varying distances. The group of journalists can be spotted through the highway rail with fighters from the self-proclaimed “Donetsk People’s Republic” (DNR).
A DNR fighter then moves toward a shell that did not detonate; it
goes off. Next he is shown dragging the body of a uniformed fighter away
from the scene.
From this video, The Interpreter has geolocated the video at the Metalist checkpoint here on Google Maps.
The checkpoint is a former post of the GAI, or Ukrainian traffic police.
A photo published on Google Maps by Sanja Belkin shows this post as it was in 2009.
The RT video shows a road sign indicating the direction to Krasny Luch:
A Parallel gas station sign can be seen on the side of the road as the fighter runs.
As the cameraman hides under the APC, he films the road, which is
going uphill, indicated by the striped railings. The gas station can be
glimpsed under the APC.
A user of Wikimapia named butilkavodi took a photo of the same gas station labelled “AGNKS” in which the sign “Metalist” is visible, which confirms the location.
Here is a diagram of the video juxtaposed on a screenshot from Google Maps:
Given the defense team’s video with cell phone records showing geolocations indicating Savchenko was captured before the journalists reached the checkpoint, and RT.com’s own video showing the camera crew deliberately loitered by a checkpoint unprotected and one crew member even hid under an APC, it appears that the criminal charges have been fabricated.
Savchenko, who is on trial in the Russian town of Rostov on the Ukrainian border, faces up to 25 years of imprisonment. Russian officials have refused to consider her a prisoner of war, enabling her case to fall under the Minsk agreement providing for POW exchanges.
— Catherine Fitzpatrick and Pierre Vaux
Fighters from the self-proclaimed “Lugansk People’s Republic” fired on Popasnaya and nearby villages, 0642.ua reported, citing the office of the Lugansk Region Military and Civilian Administration.
The night was quiet in Stanitsa Luganska, except for local shooting of firearms. About 23:00, Bolotennoye was blanketed with machine-gun fire.
Heorgiy Tuk, governor of Lugansk Region, stated (translation by The Interpreter):
In defiance of the Minsk agreements, ‘local shelling’ continues in Lugansk Region. Last night the military near Popasnaya was fired on from artillery. Today in Popasnaya, there are festivities marking Ukraine Independence Day and a ceremony to raise the State Flag. The whole town is turning out for the holiday. Despite the shelling at night, city residents are coming to honor Ukraine.
Ukraine’s Independence Day is August 24, and officials have repeatedly expressed apprehension that Russian-backed separatists will step up their attacks toward that day in an attempt to demoralize Ukrainians. Meanwhile, Russian propaganda has been insisting there is a Ukrainian build-up.
Translation: News from Donetsk: Ukrainian military are increasing forces in Donbass for a possible offensive.
Unian.net further reported from the governor’s office that the village
of Valuyskoye near Stanitsa Luganskaya was shelled and houses damaged. A
gas line was hit and 224 households were left without gas; an
electrical power line was also damaged and 500 homes left without light.
One shell hit near the city administration building.
One Ukrainian soldier was wounded near Troitskaya.
Zolotoye, a barrage of mortars damaged two homes and injured a man and
damaged a transformer, leaving the city without electricity.
homes had just been repaired recently from funds from the district
budget after the latest round of shelling from the fighters. The
terrorists most likely pounded positions in their sights previously. And
that’s how it is practically every day, they shoot and we repair. And
there is no end and no edge to this violence and destruction which the
‘Russian world’ has brought to Lugansk Region.”
Motuzyanik, speaker on ATO [anti-terrorist operation] affairs for the
presidential administration, said the situation had worsened
particularly in the direction of Mariupol:
Enemy fire on
Ukrainian lines of defense has been conducted from heavy artillery.
Notably the Ukrainian defense areas near Bogdanovka, Prokhorovka,
Starognatovka, Lebedinsky and Vinogradny to the east of Mariupol were
shelled. Residential areas of Prokhorovka were shelled from howitzers.
It was determined that shelling was coming from near Belaya Kamenka
which is controlled by the illegal armed formations. The enemy was
active on that area of the front from midnight until 10:00 am. No other
enemy provocations were recorded during the rest of the time.
He also noted shelling of ATO positions in Valuyskoye and but Schastye, Trekhizbenka, and Krymskoye were relatively quiet.
enemy is active in the west of Lugansk Region. Thus in the area of the
Bakhmutka Highway, bandit formations shelled Ukrainian defense lines
near Novotoshkovskaya with anti-tank grenade-launchers and
mortar-launchers. It was not quiet in Zolotoye. Enemy fire from
grenade-launchers began at noon and continued until late in the evening.
Then a diversionary reconnaissance group from the enemy made an attempt
to break through the line of defense in that region. After a battle the
enemy was forced to retreat. Throughout the day near Zolotoye, the
enemy used mortar-launchers, 122-mm artillery and mobile Partisan Grad
He also noted firing on Popasnaya and Troitskaya and in the Donetsk line east of the Svetlodar reservoir, there were a
number of armed provocations after midnight. West of the reservoir
violations of the ceasefire were also recorded near the village of
Zaytsevo. It was relatively quiet in the suburbs of Gorlovka, he said.
Motuzyanik said shelling continued in the area of the Donetsk Airport
and round-the-clock near Krasnogorovka and Marinka.
Meanwhile, there were a few reports of incoming shellfire in the Gorlovka suburbs.
Translation: Incoming on the outskirts #Gorlovka.
Lugansk News Today reported that the Ukrainian Security Service (SBU) arrested members of a
terrorist group reportedly coordinated and financed by Yevgeny Zhilin of
According to the SBU website, the three arrested were ex-cons
who lived in Kharkiv and had made trips to Belgorod where they were
reported to have contacted Russian intelligence. The head of the group’s
call-sign was “Tank” and a female member by the name of “Lisa” (Fox)
had joined the Ukrainian army to conduct surveillance. The group had
home-made bombs, grenades and an RPG-18 grenade launcher in their
possession at the time of arrest.
— Catherine A. Fitzpatrick